Top 5 Italian Restaurants in Pigeon Forge and Sevierville

October 20, 2021
johnny carino's italian restaurant in pigeon forge

The Smoky Mountains has a huge variety of cuisines, from Mexican to southern BBQ to Italian. Whether you’re craving decadent pasta or ooey gooey pizza, there are plenty of Italian restaurants in the area you’ll want to visit! Here are the top 5 Italian restaurants in Pigeon Forge and Sevierville you should try:

1. Mellow Mushroom

mellow mushroom pizza the islandIf you’re big on pizza, you should eat at Mellow Mushroom when you’re looking for an Italian restaurant in Pigeon Forge! They have all of the classic pizzas on their menu, as well as some unique specialties. The Merry Prankster has chicken, Italian sausage, roasted red peppers, green bell peppers, Wisconsin cheddar cheese, and an herb aioli drizzle on top. Wild in Havana is a Cuban-inspired pizza with jerk marinated pork, ham, salami, Swiss and mozzarella cheeses, diced pickles, and a mayo-mustard drizzle on top. You’ll also find calzones, salads, and sandwiches on the menu at Mellow Mushroom.

2. Johnny Carino’s

A great option for Italian food is Johnny Carino’s! Located right off the Parkway, this restaurant has everything you could want! Start out with stuffed mushrooms or fried calamari. For the main course, you can get a traditional dish, such as lasagna, fettucini, or spaghetti and meatballs. If you’re feeling adventurous, you could always try something new, like the chicken jalapeno ravioli, romano chicken, or create-your-own pasta! Of course, you can’t visit an Italian restaurant without having a traditional dessert, like tiramisu!

3. J. Del’s Pizza

j. del's pizza italian restaurant in pigeon forgeA local Italian restaurant you will want to try is J. Del’s Pizza. Tucked away off Teaster Lane, this restaurant has a variety of delicious food. Of course, you have to start out with the garlic knots. Then, choose from one of the specialty pizzas, including pepperoni, supreme, or the divisive Hawaiian pizza. You can create your own pizza and choose from a variety of toppings, or you can try one of the baked pastas, such as ziti or lasagna. Don’t forget to save room for dessert, because you’ll be able to try authentic cannolis, gelato, or Italian ice!

4. Squisito

If you want to try a locally owned Italian restaurant in Pigeon Forge or Sevierville, you should go to Squisito. This is your neighborhood Italian eatery! If you’re in the mood for mouthwatering pizza, pasta, salads, or sandwiches, this is the place for you. All of the authentic Italian dishes are made fresh from family recipes. Try the Squisito Pizza, which has pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, peppers, onions, red sauce, and mozzarella, or  get one of their famous pasta dishes!

5. Gondolier Italian Restaurant

spaghetti in tomato sauceGondolier Italian Restaurant is a great place to eat! You can get a classic pizza or create your own with an assortment of toppings. If you aren’t in the mood for pizza, try the pork tenderloin linguini, baked tortellini, baked rigatoni smothered in the sauce of your choice, lasagna, spaghetti, and so much more. You also can’t go wrong with chicken marsala, chicken piccata, shrimp and eggplant parmesan, or veal parmesan. Of course, you have to try one of the signature cheesecakes or cakes when you’ve finished your meal at Gondolier!

You’ll have a great time trying the delicious food at these Italian restaurants in Pigeon Forge and Sevierville! We know you can’t wait to come to town to try amazing food and enjoy all of the incredible attractions in the area. Start planning your next trip by booking one of our Pigeon Forge hotel rooms!